This article originally appeared in The River Reporter by Liam Mayo
As the seven libraries that are part of the Wayne Library Alliance (WLA) look toward the future, they’re making split calls on what that future will hold.
Four of the WLA’s seven libraries have decided to merge: those in Bethany, Hamlin, Newfoundland and Honesdale. They will operate as a single independent library with one of the four serving as a main branch and the rest as sub-branches, with the new model aimed at finding efficiencies and meeting state standards.
The other three have decided to stay independent: those in Lakewood, Pleasant Mount and Hawley. They see themselves as being in a good financial position, and want to retain their flexibility in serving their communities.
No service cuts are planned for either the libraries that have chosen to consolidate or for those that have not, though future negotiations on how services will be shared will be necessary as the back-end structure of library governance in Wayne County changes. Neither, too, is significant expansion planned at this time; administrators have explored changing or increasing county funding, but that’s not a necessary factor for consolidation to take place.
“If we do this well, patrons will not notice a big difference… We don’t want it to be a shock to anybody,” said Brant Ensor, administrator for the WLA.
Of the seven libraries in the Wayne Library Alliance (WLA), four (in red) have agreed to merge, and three (in green) have agreed to stay independent. Manchester Community Library, also in green, currently operates outside the WLA system as an independent library.
RR Graphic by Amanda Reed
Federation vs. consolidation
A casual observer could be forgiven for thinking the seven libraries in the WLA already operate as a consolidated system.
The vast majority of people don’t know how the library is organized or funded, said Ensor. “It’s been a big learning curve for a lot of people.”
Currently, seven of Wayne County’s libraries operate as a federated system (Not every library in Wayne County is part of the system; for example, Manchester Township has a community library that’s not part of this federation.) Under the federation model, each member library operates independently, while sharing certain services through the WLA, which is a standalone nonprofit.
“Resources shared between our member libraries include an online catalogue system, eBook and e-Audiobook lending, inter- and intra-county materials delivery service, online educational resources, and more,” reads the WLA website. “Purchasing these resources as a group helps reduce costs for member libraries.”
Consolidation
The four libraries that are choosing to consolidate want closer ties than those that currently exist through the WLA. Rather than operating as four independent libraries, collaborating within a federated system, they will operate as one library with four locations. (This will mean the federation no longer operates as such; see sidebar at right for what that will mean for shared services at the three libraries that choose not to consolidate.)
The federation model “might have been good in 1999 when this started, but it does not work today, with the cost of running a business,” said Ensor. He said that, over the past few years, the libraries had needed to cut unnecessary expenses, and that there wasn’t much more to cut. Given that situation, they decided to get out in front of their future challenges, he said.
Hamlin is “100 percent in favor of consolidation!” said Wendy Cole, library director. “Not only is it the most fiscally responsible way forward, but it also creates a community of collaboration that will benefit our patrons.”
“For Bethany, our trustees prioritized ways to keep the library open,” said Jane Bollinger, president of the Bethany Library board of trustees and a member of the consolidation steering committee. She said that Bethany is the smallest library in the county, and that, according to the consolidation study, smaller libraries are more at risk of closing.
Consolidation lets the libraries take advantage of certain efficiencies. Rather than paying the start-up costs for four separate insurance plans, for example, the consolidated library will only have to pay these costs once, an estimated savings of, conservatively, $20,000. (“Which, you know, for us is a part-time employee,” Ensor said.) The four libraries together can run one fundraising campaign, rather than confusing potential donors with four separate asks.
However, there are no cuts to service planned as part of the consolidation. “Each building is generally run autonomously,” Ensor said; the current directors will become branch managers, and angle their libraries to meet the needs of their communities the same way they do now.
“Our patrons will see no change in our day-to-day operations, because we will continue to serve them and provide programming and access in the ways we do now; but behind the scenes, we will be much more efficient and cohesive, leading to a better use of funding,” said Cole.
“The patrons won’t see much difference at all,” said Bollinger. “Most of the difference is in the structure of how the libraries will run and be managed.”
A concern for libraries early on the process was the question of whether libraries would lose their individual character, said Bollinger. However, she said, each library has the option of keeping a friends group or an advisory council, so they can stay in touch with both the higher-up governing structure and with their community.
Independence
Despite the arguments in favor, not every library in Wayne County was convinced.
Hawley’s public library is one of those that has chosen not to join the consolidation. According to director Amy Conklin, the library’s community legacy is a major reason for the decision.
“This library was built by our community,” she said. The library had its start with women trading books on Main Street, she said; the building itself was a gift to a local attorney from her steelworker husband.
At the other end of Wayne County, in Lakewood, PA, Amy Payne, director of the Northern Wayne Community Library (NWCL), tells a similar story. “A small group of ladies started this 34 years ago,” said Payne, those being community members who saw the need for a library on their own.”
The different communities in Wayne County are different in aspect, she said. “Our rural community is very independent.”
While history played a role, both Conklin and Payne emphasize that their libraries did not make the decision based on a fear of change. There were hundreds, even thousands of pages of materials studying the possibility of consolidation, they said; library staff and board members read those materials forward and backward.
“We just felt like this was the best decision for us,” said Conklin.
The anticipated loss of financial autonomy played a large role in both library’s decisions. Both Hawley and the NWCL have significant reserves, according to Conklin and Payne; if they joined a consolidated system, both would have to surrender those reserves to the consolidated whole. Both libraries have built up those reserves through frugal budgeting and through a reliance on the work fo volunteers.
In addition, both libraries have a strong amount of support from their respective communities, and see that support as their way of remaining sustainable into the future.
Hawley’s library has a very robust board and friends group, said Conklin. She added that not every library in the county sees that level of engagement, and those that don’t would probably prefer consolidation.
Everyone in the Northern Wayne community the NWCL has talked to supports the library staying independent, said Payne. The library has had good support from individuals, businesses and the county at large, and it anticipates that support will continue.
“We’re betting on our community to keep us going as long as we meet their needs,” said Payne.
The status of the libraries
| County aid | State aid | Shared services |
| The consolidation can go forward with or without any changes to the library’s county funding. However, the study did outline ways the county could up its support of its libraries. There are three options, Ensor said: the formation of a library authority, which would impose its own fees on users within the district like a sewer or water authority; a county-wide library tax, which would be imposed by Wayne County’s government; or an increase in the current level of funding provided through the current system, whereby the county grants libraries monies from its general fund. None of those options are being considered at this time, said Ensor; consolidation is its own process, and will conclude before conversations about money really get underway. However, he said, discussion about increased funding will have to be had at some point to completely fulfill the aims of consolidation. Currently, the implementation timeline presented in the consolidation study’s executive study projects that there will be fee-on-tax bills in the year 2029. The lag between consolidation and increased support was a concern for Hawley, said Conklin. She said that the uncertainty there increased the risk that the library might end up with service levels that weren’t what was presented. | One of the cases made for consolidation involves the requirements necessary for libraries to receive state aid. Pennsylvania requires libraries that receive state aid to meet certain standards, in areas such as hours open and staff certifications. However, state regulations allow the state to waive those standards if state aid to libraries does not increase year over year. Pennsylvania has not updated its library funding since 2003. Because of that, it hasn’t enforced its library standards in that same time. There are “rumblings” that the state requirements will start to be enforced at some point, said Ensor. According to him, only Newfoundland currently meets all of the requirements for an independent library. As a single consolidated library, state standards will be different. The library’s main branch will need to meet higher standards than those its sub-branches will need to meet. | Currently, some services get shared between all seven Wayne County libraries through the WLA. While those services can’t be provided through the same framework once the federation dissolves, library staff are hopeful other agreements can be worked out. Some amount of state funding gets designated as county coordination funding, said Ensor. That money has to be spent on services that help all libraries in the county. Even apart from that, individual libraries have options to keep offering the same shared services the federation helps them provide now. They can contract with the new consolidated library to keep providing those services, or they can go directly to the vendors themselves. Conklin said that Hawley hopes they can work out an agreement with the new library system. “But if not, we’re going to do it ourselves.” |








