LIBERTY, N.Y. – A group of residents, employees, and residents’ families of the Sullivan County Adult Care Center have filed a lawsuit seeking to stop the closure of the facility.
The Article 78 proceeding was filed with the Supreme Court of the State of New York of Sullivan County on Tuesday against Sullivan County, Sullivan County Manager Joshua Potosek, and the New York State’s Department of Health.
Article 78 proceedings allow people to challenge decisions or actions by state and local government agencies.
The county announced on Aug. 19 that the Sullivan County Adult Care Center, known as the Care Center at Sunset Lake in Liberty, would abruptly close due to ongoing financial challenges and inability to transfer operations.
READ: Sullivan Care Center at Sunset Lake to Close After Years of Financial, Management Woes
The proceeding documents reviewed by Radio Catskill allege that the closure decision “flagrantly violated the New York Open Meetings Law,” along with other state laws including the New York Freedom of Information Law, the New York Public Health Law, and the state’s Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act.
The lawsuit further alleges that the county “deliberately concealed the substance, timing, and finality of the closure decision from residents, families, employees, and the public at large for FIVE months. Further, respondent New York State Department of Health (“DOH”) participated in the closure process in a secretive and undisclosed manner, and any determination or approval issued by DOH in connection with the proposed closure was similarly long withheld from Petitioners and the public.”
County legislators said that the vote to close the Care Center occurred during a closed-door executive session on March 26, but there’s no public record of the vote.
The group is represented by civil rights attorney Michael Sussman, who successfully represented residents and employees at Orange County’s Valley View nursing home in 2014 to overturn a local vote to sell the nursing home.
“[The Care Center has] become a staple and relied upon by many people for assistance, whether rehabilitation assistance or long-term residential assistance when they age or have the need,” said Sussman.
The petitioners are asking for a permanent injunction to keep the facility open until Sullivan County fully comply with the state’s Open Meetings Law, hold a public hearing, and disclose an independent fiscal audit and resident-impact assessment on the closure.
Radio Catskill reached out to Sullivan County for comment, but the county’s communications director Dan Hust said it was unable to comment on ongoing litigation. New York’s Department of Health did not immediately respond for comment.
Facility’s residents transition to new homes, raise concerns
Since Sullivan County announced the closure in August, some residents have raised concerns about the closure process during county legislative meetings.
Lou Setren, president of the facility’s family council, said families and residents were stunned by the closure announcement, some of whom found out on social media.
“There seemed to have been little regard for what’s referred to as ‘transfer trauma,’” said Setren, explaining that some residents were allegedly abruptly moved to different units during their lunch periods in an effort to quickly consolidate residents.
“It is traumatic for residents who have become accustomed to a space to suddenly be uprooted and moved to another room, whether it’s even on the same unit or a different unit.”
District 5 Legislator Cat Scott said Legislators Brian McPhillips, Matt Matt McPhillips, Luis Alvarez, and herself voted against closing the facility during the March 2026 vote.
District 9 Legislator Terry Blosser-Bernardo said she wasn’t present during the vote, leaving both legislators and the public confused how the vote could have passed without a majority.
Sullivan County has operated the 146-bed care center for more than 30 years. The facility has long faced financial challenges and brought in Infinite Care to manage operations in 2021. Since then, the facility’s health inspections have significantly declined.
The Care Center has 34 long-term residents as of Sept. 11, far less than the 93 residents the county first started with when it announced the closure.
Now, the lawsuit is with Supreme Court Justice Judge Stephan Schick to review if the order shows cause for a temporary restraining order, says Sussman.
Setren says at the very least he hopes the lawsuit holds the county accountable.
“They need to follow the letter and the spirit of the law before they take any action, and it’s up to a judge to decide whether they had, in fact, done this in the proper manner.”
Some county legislators have been trying to sell or close the Sullivan County Adult Care Center for many years, despite the fact that it has always seemed that a majority of the residents wanted it to remain open and operated by the county. It seems likely that at least some of those elected officials who voted to shutter the facility will pay a price at the next election of the county legislators.
who will be purchasing the land and building now?