Middletown Adopts 2027 Budget as Federal Lawsuit Escalates Dispute in Jewett
The Town of Middletown has adopted a $4.8 million budget for 2027, keeping its tax levy below the state-mandated cap despite rising costs and concerns over salary increases for town employees. Meanwhile, in Greene County, a dispute involving elected officials in the Town of Jewett has escalated into a federal lawsuit.
Matt Avitabile of the The Mountain Eagle joined Radio Catskill’s Patricio Robayo to discuss both developments and their potential impact on local government.
In Delaware County, Middletown officials approved a spending plan that includes a 5% salary increase for all town employees, including council members and Town Supervisor Glenn Faulkner.
According to Avitabile, the town used $117,000 from its unappropriated fund balance, money left over from previous years, to help keep the tax levy below the state’s cap.
The salary increases drew criticism from some residents during the public hearing on November 10. Avitabile said the raises followed negotiations with the town’s highway union, which secured annual increases of 5% over three years. Town officials decided to extend the same increase to other employees for 2027.
Last year’s budget included a 3% salary increase, which also generated public discussion.
Faulkner defended the decision, saying the town wants to provide competitive wages to retain employees. Councilmember Brian Sweeney also supported the increases, arguing that town workers should be treated fairly.
The budget comes as municipalities across the region face higher expenses for health insurance, retirement contributions, fuel and other operating costs.
Avitabile said some communities have faced tax increases exceeding 20% as multiple financial pressures converge. Middletown, however, was able to adopt its spending plan without exceeding the state tax cap.
While Middletown officials have finalized their budget, another Catskills community is dealing with a growing legal controversy.
In Greene County, Jewett Highway Superintendent Robert Mallory and Town Clerk Maya Carl have filed a federal lawsuit against the town and individual members of its town board, including Town Supervisor Greg Croyer.
The lawsuit includes allegations of retaliation, discrimination and civil conspiracy stemming from disputes over town policies and the treatment of elected officials.
According to Avitabile, the conflict began with disagreements over policies involving security systems, credit card use and health care. Mallory and Carl previously challenged those measures, arguing that they interfered with their ability to carry out their elected duties and represented an abuse of power.
The federal complaint alleges that the town’s actions caused financial losses, emotional distress and damage to the officials’ professional reputations. The plaintiffs are seeking a jury trial, although no specific dollar amount for damages has been established.
The allegations have not been proven in court.
The legal battle is also unfolding alongside an investigation by the Greene County Sheriff’s Office.
Avitabile reported that three search warrants have been executed as part of an investigation into what Sheriff’s Captain Joel Rohrer described as allegations of potentially fraudulent activity.
The investigation remains ongoing, and the interview did not establish any findings of criminal wrongdoing.
Avitabile said the town supervisor has disputed the severity of the misconduct allegations.
The controversy could continue well into 2027 as the federal lawsuit moves through the courts. Before the case can proceed to discovery, a judge may need to address preliminary legal questions, including jurisdiction and whether the claims can move forward.
During the interview, Robayo noted that an online court listing indicated an initial conference scheduled for February 10, 2027, although Avitabile said he had not independently confirmed the date.
Avitabile said additional details about the lawsuit and the sheriff’s investigation are expected to emerge as the legal process continues.
The Mountain Eagle plans to continue reporting on the developments in Jewett.