Ulster County Judge Kevin Bryant published his latest findings on Wednesday, further explaining the court’s temporary injunction order that halts the Adult Care Center closure in Liberty.
On Monday, Bryant ruled to issue a temporary injunction to temporarily halt the closure in a major victory for healthcare advocates.
A group of residents, employees, and family members sued Sullivan County and the state’s health department earlier this month citing procedural violations after the county announced it would close the 146-bed facility.
READ: Lawsuit Filed to Stop Sullivan Adult Care Center Closure, Citing Flagrant Procedural Violations
Sullivan County’s Communications Director Dan Hust told Radio Catskill only 12 residents are living at the Care Center as of Sept. 23 – significantly down from the 93 residents the facility started with when it announced the closure on Aug. 19 five weeks prior.
The 12-page court filing details that the court found the lawsuit’s petitioners established “a likelihood and probability of success” that Sullivan County failed to comply with the Open Meetings Law when it voted to close the facility in a closed-door executive session on March 26.
“There is no indication that there were substantive discussions in public regarding the closure, no clarification as to what documents, information, reports or opinions the legislators were considering, and no dialogue amongst the legislators regarding their reasons and rationale for their votes,” the court filing states.
Michael Sussman, the attorney representing the lawsuit’s plaintiffs, says the findings are “a very strong renunciation of [the county’s] position.”
The case was moved to Ulster Court after five Sullivan County judges recused themselves from proceedings.
Some question whether county is following court order
While the facility’s closure plan has been temporarily halted, Sussman says he’s worried whether the temporary injunction is being followed.
“I’m deeply concerned both with the process that led us to where we are but also with where we are right now and whether the county is complying,” said Sussman.

Lou Setren, president of the facility’s family council, said that following the court’s initial temporary restraining order, Setren was told by Care Center administrators he was not allowed past the front desk.
He was also told that residents are still allegedly being pressured to develop a transfer or discharge plan.
“Family members had been advised that if a placement was not found, they got a 30-day notice that their family member would be discharged home, regardless of whether the family had the means to provide appropriate care for the resident,” said Setren.
Sullivan County District 5 Legislator Cat Scott said that she visited the Care Center on Sept. 23 and was also told by security that she could not enter the facility past the front desk without administrative approval – a move that Scott said has never happened during her time as a county legislator.
“I went to the Care center yesterday just because this closure has all happened so incredibly fast,” said Scott. “It’s been a whirlwind.”
Hust said that Sullivan County officials and employees have not pressured any resident to leave the Care Center.
“Residents are aware that the closure process is paused and that they are free to choose to stay in the facility or seek alternate accommodations of their own accord,” said Hust. “If a departure is chosen, that decision is solely made by the resident and/or their authorized caregiver, and the County cannot hold residents against their will.”
Sullivan County said that all residents and employees have been made aware of the court order.
Scott said she wants the public to know to hold county legislators accountable.
“If you do not express those thoughts and feelings to the legislature [and] your elected representative, then they’re gonna operate however they want to operate in a vacuum.”
Editor’s Note: A previous version of this story said that Sussman said the court filing was a renunciation of the judge’s position. He was referencing the county’s position.