The Sullivan County Legislature voted on Thursday to close the Adult Care Center in a 5-4 vote.
Legislators Cat Scott, Matt McPhillips, Luis Alvarez, and Terry Blosser-Bernardo voted against closing the 146-bed facility. Legislators Brian McPhillips, Nicholas Salomone, Nadia Rajsz, Joe Perrello, and Amanda Ward voted to close the Liberty facility.
Sullivan County first announced the closure on Aug. 19, citing financial challenges and inability to transfer operations to the county.
“The majority of my colleagues and I agreed that taxpayers cannot afford to continue the costly operation of the Care Center while facing enormous revenue losses and quickly increasing costs throughout County government,” said Legislature Chair Nadia Rajsz in the closure statement.
Some residents quickly pushed back on the announcement at subsequent legislative meetings, questioning when the closure decision was ever made.
On Sept. 11, a group of residents, families, and employees sued Sullivan County citing procedural violations in the closure process.
Ulster County Judge Kevin Bryant temporarily halted the closure, finding that Sullivan County likely violated New York’s Open Meetings Law when it voted to close the facility in a closed-door executive session on March 26 and likely caused “irreparable harm” to residents and employees.
READ: Judge Finds Sullivan County Likely Violated State Law in Care Center Closure Decision
How the legislature’s vote on Thursday affects the future of the pending lawsuit is unclear.
Michael Sussman – the attorney representing the lawsuit’s plaintiffs – said the court order to temporarily halt the facility is still in effect regardless of the vote.
“The injunction remains in full force in effect, and it will remain in full force in effect until there’s a subsequent order from the court order, one way or the other,” Sussman told Radio Catskill.
During the special meeting, the county legislature passed a resolution to authorize the closure of the Adult Care Center and authorize County Manager Joshua Potosek to issue an RFP to identify an alternative operator to provide nursing home services in the facility.
Sullivan County Deputy Attorney Khalid Bashjawish said that he advised the legislature that a public closure vote before Oct. 19 could help dismiss the lawsuit. Oct. 19 is when responses are due from both legal parties before the judge makes a decision.
“This resolution, in my view as I mentioned to the legislature, it would make most of the complaints and the allegations in the petition moot,” said Bashjawish on Thursday.
Legislator Cat Scott, who voted to keep the facility open, said she was disappointed by the final vote. “We have gone into this with a speed that does not respect the public or the public good that we are stripping.”
Before the roll-call vote, Scott made a motion to invoke Rule 40 – which would have delayed the vote – but the majority of the legislature overrode her motion. Now, Scott’s worried what privatizing senior care operations will mean for the county-owned nursing home.
“How do private operators run it? There’s a profit here, and I know how they do it, right? They do it by reducing things here and there, so when you make reductions, you also reduce care,” said Scott, who chairs the county’s Health & Human Services Committee.
Sullivan County’s Communications Director Dan Hust confirmed only six residents remain at the Care Center as of Oct. 1 – far less than the 93 residents the facility started with when it announced the closure in August.

Several dozen residents spoke out against the closure, with only one person speaking in favor of the closure. Joy Wood, a former administrator at the Roscoe Rehabilitation & Nursing Center, said she wishes Sullivan County could keep the facility open but doesn’t think it’s possible.
“I don’t think any county can manage a nursing home today. It’s very, very complicated. It’s not for the faint of heart, and the things that I could do six years ago [I] can’t do today,” said Wood. “You didn’t have great staffing numbers before COVID, you had terrible staffing numbers during COVID, and you’ve had terrible staffing numbers since.”
County resident Kathy Kreiter said one Care Center resident, Victor Ocasio, whom she’d been an advocate for, was moved to a facility in Kingston last week and didn’t feel he had been given a meaningful choice in the process.
“ The people who live [at the Care Center] are not simply residents on a list. They are members of our community. They have relationships with their caregivers, families, friends, advocates, and the people who have known them for years. Moving them away from that community has consequences that cannot be measured simply by finding another bed in another facility,” said Kreiter.
Legislator Brian McPhillips said during the meeting he doesn’t have faith that the county can appropriately run the facility. He’s hopeful that the resolution will clear the way for an interested healthcare provider to step in.
“When [the announcement] became public, we were inundated with interest levels. [It] is part of the reason it gives me a little bit of hope that there will be a quick application process through this RFP,” said McPhillips.
Still, some residents worry about what this means for the future of Sullivan County. Former New York Assemblymember Aileen Gunther, who represented the 100th Assembly District from 2013 to 2025, said she was “very disappointed.”
“I don’t think [the vote] means moving forward,” said Gunther. “I think there’s so many families that have their family member in that facility. Honestly, I think they’re doing the wrong thing. We need it in Sullivan County.”